books
St Thomas' Brampton and St Peter's Holymoorside, Chesterfield
Book, Poem and Film Reviews
Our vision statement: Sharing the love of Jesus
reading

Home
Church Magazine
A series of book reviews by chuch members. Taken from the Church Magazine

1989 "Promised Land" -by Michele Guinness
1991 "Beginning Where I Am" -Godfrey Holmes
1992 "Brushing Up On Believing" -by Gavin Reid and Shelagh Brown
1992 "A Passion for Holiness" -by J.I. Packer
1992 "Explaining Your Faith Without Losing Your Friends" -by Alistair McGrath
1993 "The Global Consumer" -by Phil Wells and Mandy Jeller
1993 "How to Rescue the Earth Without Worshipping Nature" -by Tony Campolo
1993 "Church on the Threshold: Renewing the Local Church" -by Cyril Ashton
1993 "Threshold God" -by Cyril Ashton
1994 "Going Home" (What to do when somebody dies) -by Michael Cole
1995 "Facing the Storm" -by Eddie Askew
1995 "Tales From The Ark" -by Avril Rowlands
1995 "Signs of Revival" -by Patrick Dixon
1995 "Maximus Mouse" -by Brian Ogden
1995 "Haffertees First Easter" -by J & J Perkins
1995 "The Mini Easter Book"
1995 "The Windy Day" -by Teddy Horsley (and the Holy Spirit)
1995
"The Hard Sayings of Jesus" -by FF Bruce
1995 "Where does the Sea Go?" -by Jan Godfrey
1995 "After The Fire" -by John Lockley
1995 "Telling the Sea" -by Pauline Fisk
1995 "Created for Love: understanding and building self-esteem" -by J and A Stuart
1995 "The Cat's Tail -Jesus at the Wedding" -by Nick Butterworth and Mick Inkpen
1995 "The Grumpy Shepherd" -by Lynn Waller
1996"How Do We Know The Bible Is True?" -by Paddie Devon
1996 "Miracle in Mostar" -by Gerard Kelly and Lowell Sheppard
1999"Windows on the Cross" -by Tom Smail
2000 "Cover to Cover Through the Bible As It Happened" -a help to reading the complete Bible
2000 Harry Potter - Brilliant Idea or Bad Influence?
2001 "Listen and Live" - Using the Bible in Prayer
2002 Two Children's Books Reviewed
2002 A Perfect Gift for Christmas -A few books reviewed
2003 "A Life Worth Living" – Exploring the Meaning of Life by Nicky Gumbel
2005 "Lift the Label" -the hidden cost of our lifestyle by David Westlake and Esther Stansfield
2006 "Fuelling the Fire – Fresh Thinking on Prayer" -Dennis Lennon
2006 "Builders and Fools: Leadership the Bible Way" -Derek Tiball
2006 "The Jesus I Never Knew" -Philip Yancey
2008 "The Herodian Stones" -Gaynor Taylor
2008 The "Good Stuff" Review: "The Straight Story" -Peter Cooney
2008 Two Books for Advent ‘The Meaning is in the Waiting: The Spirit of Advent’ and ‘The Shack’ -Matt Barnes
2008 "The Meaning is in the Waiting: The Spirit of Advent" -Reviewed by Millie Guthrie
2009 "The Shack" -Reviewed by Millie Guthrie
2009 The 'Good Stuff' Review: "Sophie Scholl – The Last Days" -Peter Cooney
2010 "Suprised by Hope" -review by Carolyn Baker
2010 "The Divine Image" -commentry on William Blake's poem by Paula Simons
2011 "The Radical Disciple" -review by Sue Wheeler
2011 "Chariots of Fire" -30 years on
2011 "Son of Man" -film review


"Promised Land" (June 1989 edition of magazine)

by Michele Guinness

'Guinness is good for you"

A few weeks ago when I was browsing through the biography section of the library I came across "Promised Land" by Michele Guinness.

Michele tells the tale of the first few months as a new curate's wife in a West Yorkshire town during the build up to the miner's strike. Her first impressions of the town, the church and the curate's house are depressing to say the least, but as she explores the possibilities of the parish and the characters within the community her obvious sense of humour and zest for life shine out from the text. Some of us may find her shrewd observations on the running of the church a little bit too close to home for comfort. I certainly recognised familiar problems and excuses!

The book is entertaining as a straight forward account of church life in a close-knit, though depressed, mining community. Once you realise that Michele Guiness was born into a Jewish family her commentary seems all the more poignant.

If this brief introduction leaves you wanting to know more about the Jewess from the North East who became a Christian, actively involved in church life, that’s exactly how I felt. Through our bookstall I acquired a copy of "Child of the Covenant" another extremely humorous and readable account of her life, in which Michele Guinness describes how she comes to be 'A Jew completed by Christ'. It gave me several things to think about, particulary as I finished the book shortly before our Passover Meal in church.

I recommend both books to you in the hope that you will enjoy them as much as I did. I'm looking forward to the third installment of her story and believe you will feel the same. I do hope Michele Guinness is still finding time to put pen to paper!

Pat Morgan


"Beginning Where I Am" (April 1991 edition of magazine)

St Thomas’ Gives Birth to a New Religious Paperback

Godfrey Holmes, a Chesterfield Social Worker who lives on Yew Tree Estate has written a book which will appeal to all young people aged 14 to 21.

It is called BEGINNING WHERE I AM: Meditations for Young People, Published by S.P.C.K. Triangle March 1991, price £2.99p.

At the Youth Service on March 3rd., Godfrey talked to Christopher Frith about his writing, this book especially, and a prayer was said to dedicate BEGINNING WHERE I AM as it begins its travels to bookshops and bookstalls in Britain and overseas.

A review follows.


Beginning Where I Am

By Godfrey Holmes

"Beginning where teenagers are Godfrey Holmes explores the issues they are facing now .... "

This how the review begins on the back cover of the book and I do agree with that to a certain extent. The author certainly can relate to teenagers, which is apparent with his easy to read style.

The book is set out with a chapter based around prayer and meditation, and then follows with typical questions youngsters might ask on the subject of meditation. Out of the 113 pages of "Beginning where I am", 96 are devoted to meditations Godfrey has written. These are then to be used by the readers, if so desired. This proportion seemed quite high to me as I thought the readers should be encouraged to write their own prayers. However, the author does include some topical subjects; for example:

i) I've started smoking
ii) I don't want to die
iii) I don't want to look for work
or iv) Why was I born?

These are I'm sure issues adults could echo never mind the children. Other topics covered are bullying, friendships, arguments within families, addictions and beliefs. Quite a lot for you to get your teeth into! This is a book to be chewed over, (not literally) consumed and hopefully put into practice when issues arise. It might even be good for parents to read, so that they can understand the problems facing young people in today's society.

So people, part with your hard earned cash and buy a copy. Teenagers, be encouraged to read it because it will hopefully guide you to the One who truly understands (not just pretends to!). I'm talking of course about the Big Guy .... GOD.

Review by Naomi Redhead


"Brushing Up On Believing" (October 1992 edition of magazine)

by Gavin Reid and Shelagh Brown, £3.95

Which came first: evangelism or knowledge? Nevertheless, Gavin Reid and Shelagh Brown have written and admirable summary of Christian principles entitled "Brushing Up On Believing" to partner their "Lights That Shine" outreach study book. Described as a fresh look at basic Christianity and prayer it has much to commend it: clearly written with relevant bible passages to refer to, and short and concise chapters, plus study helps. If you remember points from images or pictures there are cartoons to help!


"A Passion for Holiness" (December 1992 edition of magazine)

by J.I. Packer Crossway Books, £5.99

If we happen to be among those who view holiness as an affliction of the over-pious, or as an excess to be avoided with pride, we may find the title of this book somewhat off putting.

However, one thing becomes clear after only a single reading through. "A Passion for Holiness", to borrow words from the marriage service, " ..is not to be entered into unadvisedly or lightly". It is challenging, heart-searching, thought provoking and thoroughly practical; practical, not in the sense of being a D.I.Y. manual for spiritual growth, but in rescuing the idea of holiness from being a monastic speciality. It is for you and me now, in 1992, in Chesterfield. In no way does it recommend a retreat from daily life. The Gospel message, ourselves and our daily living in response to our Holy God are discussed with almost prophetic frankness.

Of the word ''holiness', the author says: "In its application to people, God's 'holy ones' or 'saints', the word implies both devotion and assimilation: devotion, in the sense of a life of service to God; assimilation, in the sense of imitating, conforming to and becoming like the God one serves. For Christians, this means taking God's moral laws as our rule and God's incarnate Son as our model; this is where our analysis of holiness must start".

In all, this is not a book to read should we wish to remain static in our Christian life or outside it as a critical spectator. Here is a call for personal commitment, in all moral seriousness, to living humbly and obediently before God. Indeed, J.I. Packer does "bring us back to where God wants us to be " a holy people.

Speaking of this book, Richard Foster, author of "A Celebration of Discipline" (which we studied in Open House Groups a while back), says:"This (book) will take our best thinking and our most faithful living". We have been warned.

David Smith


"Explaining Your Faith Without Losing Your Friends" (December 1992 edition of magazine)

by Alistair McGrath, £1.95

The book originated as a series of lectures to university students preparing for college mission. It was specifically intended for that age group but it does have wider appeal and it does lead in by looking at what most of us fear most about sharing the Christian faith...overcoming our own doubts and other's objections. 109 pages of helpful material probing and answering basic questions.


"The Global Consumer" -Best Buys to Help the Third World (February 1993 edition of magazine)

by Phil Wells and Mandy Jeller

"Famine, ecological disaster. We are all aware of the global crisis but few of us realise the power we have to help bring about permanent change. Many of the things we buy daily have a direct effect on the Third World: some fuel the cycle of poverty and environmental destruction, others can help to break it ...."

So goes the introduction to the "Global Consumer".

Have you ever felt guilty for instance, about drinking tea and coffee, or eating oranges and bananas grown and picked by poorly paid labourers; or buying clothes made abroad by workers in squalid conditions, when multi-national companies cream off profits. I know that I have - or felt powerless to do anything except frustratingly and guiltily going along with the masses.

Although this is not specifically a Christian book, it sets out to inform and to help us to understand the effects of our purchases - and to choose wisely what to buy and what to avoid. It covers such diverse subjects as tea, coffee, chocolate, fruit, sugar, clothes and furniture to name but a few.

Its style is easily readable and well set out. One word of warning though. This book can make you feel frustrated and angry at the lack of concern that most multi-national companies have for God's world, and those who work for them, especially in the Third World. There is an absence of a lot of information but as you read you will realise the complexity of your seemingly cost-conscious decision to buy X or Y jar of coffee - and much more!

'If you read this book, please don't be overawed by the vast range of issues it covers in a relatively short space but be determined to use it prayerfully to heighten your awareness and exercise your rights as a consumer.


"How to Rescue the Earth Without Worshipping Nature" (June 1993 edition of magazine)

Tony Campolo, Word Books, £4.25, 1992

In a fast, racy style Tony Campolo urges Christians to take on board the issues of environmentalists and realise that the bible teaches us to care for God's creation. The situation is urgent concerning pollution, depletion of resources and cruelty to animals. He discusses the approach of different Christian thinkers to creation, as well as noting the changing attitude in the scientific community towards the natural world.

The second half of the book is more practical and challenging. Issues of simple lifestyle and commitment to social justice as part of Christian discipleship are raised. An individual can make a difference, so will you think about your use of the car, about saving water, about recycling materials or caring for animals? Also you can pray for forgiveness in our destruction of the environment, for God to act and for Christians to understand their responsibility to care for God's creation.

The book is useful if only for the final two chapters. Here Tony Campolo gives clear warnings to keep out of the New Age movement, by recognising the differences from Christianity. He concludes with "The Heart of the Matter: Environmentalism as the fruit of the Spirit" where he uses Galatians 5:22 to 23 to describe a way of life spirituality with creation-care.

The book is aimed at American evangelicals but it has a clear message for us in Chesterfield. Are we willing to listen and to change?

Sheila Pite


"Church on the Threshold: Renewing the Local Church" (December 1993 edition of magazine)

Cyril Ashton, published by Daybreak, £7.95

Renewal? What's that? What's it got to do with St Thomas Brampton?

Cyril Ashton writes that renewal is "essentially a movement of the Holy Spirit to restore and re-invigorate the whole Church." But I said what's it got to do with St Thomas Brampton? He elaborates: "The Holy Spirit is not static. Having moved in, He moves on, expecting the whole Church to move with Him. The church is either on the way, or in the way."

In what must be the most balanced and helpful book I've ever encountered on the subject, Cyril Ashton sensitively imparts a compelling vision of a church filled with the Holy Spirit and fulfilling its mission in the world.

But how? This is a practical book and especially so, as Cyril draws on immense personal experience at the forefront of renewal in the Church of England. He shows how by rediscovering a proper role for the laity in the church, where leadership is shared and all the gifts of the Spirit are operating in liberty, the church can be renewed and move on to recapture its apostolic nature, vision and power.

Doesn't sound anything like St Thomas? It certainly doesn't. But that's a church on the threshold says Cyril: "Many believe that the Church's spiritual poverty has brought it to the threshold of new things." Caught the vision? If you still can't see that it matters to St Thomas then read the book. If you can, then read the book and let it happen.

Paul Uden


"Threshold God" (December 1993 edition of magazine)

by Cyril Ashton, Daybreak DLT, £7.95

The subtitle of this, Cyril's second book is 'Discovering Christ in the Margins of life.' In it he argues that 'the cross symbolizes for all time that God meets us in the place of shame and failure, turning defeat into life and growth.' A moment later he writes 'God turns things inside out. With him the shadowy margins of life become the threshold through which we move into greater wholeness.'

For him a threshold is a place of growth, where you take risks and step out from the known to the unknown.

By using bible passages, Christian writers and stories from his personal experience Cyril gently encourages us on our own pilgrimages, to cross our individual thresholds and so to grow as Christians. Some of the chapter headings may give you a flavour of this book. 'The Search for God' and 'A ridiculous Love' discusses our seeking for God and God's amazing love for us. 'Strength and Weakness' where, I quote again 'The truly strong are those who are prepared to face up to the inner reality and stay with it as the Holy Spirit brings transformation and wholeness.' 'The void of loneliness' with a discussion of the importance of solitude and silence leads into the chapter 'The Journey into God.' Then there is 'Defeating Giants' - how to move from fear to faith and 'Sexuality and Spirituality' with the recognition of the vital importance of this area of our lives.

The final chapter 'The Song of Ascents' challenges us to continue on our pilgrimage.

The book can be read quickly and then reread, and read again. The stories are real and illustrate the text. There are many gems and it is a book which I will give to friends this Christmas and return to frequently.

Sheila Pite


"Going Home" (What to do when somebody dies) (April 1994 edition of magazine)

by Michael Cole, Vicar of All Saints, Woodford Green Essex, Highland Books, Paperback £3.99

As we approach Easter and think about the death of Jesus, maybe this is a good time to think about our own mortality.

In our society, death is a taboo subject and is spoken of in whispers. In this very readable book, Going Home, Michael Cole says "A right attitude to death will bring a right attitude to life and a right attitude to ourselves will bring us a right attitude to God and to the Lord Jesus. When these things are true we can look upon death as "going home".

It is full of examples of personal experience and the experience of those he has come into contact with in his ministry. It is easy to read and full of helpful and practical advice. He looks at bereavement from an adult and a child's point of view, how we can be prepared for death, making of wills, saying ‘goodbye'. He tries to give helpful, reassuring explanations to our questions and doubts and succeeds in giving encouragement and hope.

This book is written, not just for those who have faced bereavement but also for those who have a concern about the future, about heaven and eternity.

Michael Cole's prayer is that none of us are fearful of going home.'

Jackie Bradley


"Facing the Storm" (February 1995 edition of magazine)

Author: Eddie Askew, £2.25, published by The Leprosy Mission International

I wish I had listened to my friend Caroline when she recommended Eddie Askew's books on prayer and meditation. Having just read "Facing the Storm" (the 5th book in a series of six) I now realise just what I've been missing!!

At £2.25 (as are all the books) this book is further enhanced by author's own water colour paintings throughout.

I could really relate to the prayer based on Hebrews 12 v - 2 on page 47 concerning rushing around in a panic and going round in circles!!

It concludes with, "Help me to differentiate the urgent from the important. To hear, behind the clamorous voice of now, your gentle voice that offers me, so quietly, the joy of knowing why I'm here, and who stands close".

I can wholeheartedly recommend any of Eddie Askews books to anyone wanting to walk along pathways of thought and insight into a deeper understanding of life in Christ.

Pauline Latimer


"Tales From The Ark" (February 1995 edition of magazine)

Author: Avril Rowlands, £3.50, Lion Publishing

Thomas and I loved this book of "what might have happened on board the Ark". Nearly every chapter is centred on an animal or insect, my personal favourite being "The Spiders Tale" where Noah is afraid of the two spiders who have taken up residence in his cabin (I could sympathise with him there!!)

Poor Noah has problems with some of the animals wanting to eat each other, a leaking Ark, a power struggle between the lion and the tiger, and a food shortage, just to name a few!

A very funny book which would appeal to any one aged 3 to 103!!

Pauline Latimer


"Signs of Revival" (April 1995 edition of magazine)

Author: Dr Patrick Dixon, Kingsway, £7.99

Have you heard of the "Toronto Blessing" and wondered whether this is a move of God or mass hysteria? What is the biblical basis for "Resting or falling in the Spirit" or are people just pushed? People say it has happened before. Does this make what is happening now unimportant or very significant?

Dr Dixon did not know what to make of these strange happenings in British Churches in 1994 so he decided to find out. This book certainly answered many of my questions and I highly recommend it.

Pauline Latimer
"Maximus Mouse" (April 1995 edition of magazine)

Author: Brian Ogden, Scripture Union £2.99

Over 300 children sat captivated as I read them the stories of Maximus Mouse. Each entertaining story makes an important point, is followed by a prayer and is just the right length for a junior assembly. Excellent for reading at home but a must for anyone short of ideas for assemblies.

Pauline Latimer
"Hafferties First Easter" (April 1995 edition of magazine)

Author: J. & J. Perkins, Lion Publishing, £2.25

At first glance, the Easter Story and the experiences of Haffertee, a toy hamster, would appear to be poles apart! And yet, the two are cleverly drawn together on a parallel, with depth and sensitivity enabling a young child to understand what Easter is all about.

There is more to this little book than meets the eye! It is one of a series of six Haffertee books.

For age 4 upwards.

Pauline Latimer
"The Mini Easter Book" (April 1995 edition of magazine)

Lion Publishing, 99p

This book combines the story of the first Easter with an activity book of relevant things to do over the Easter holiday. Remarkable value for 99p.

For age 5 upwards.

Pauline Latimer


"The Windy Day" (June 1995 edition of magazine)

Author: Teddy Horsley (and the Holy Spirit), Bible Society, 99p

This simple story focuses on a puzzled bear called Teddy Horsley, who gradually comes to understand about the Holy Spirit by comparing the effects of a particularly windy day to the effects of the Holy Spirit at his church, who are celebrating Pentecost.

Neither can be seen, but, unlike the wind, the Holy Spirit makes the people happy, and Teddy Horsley feel loved and secure.

The ideal book to have available (especially at this time of the year) when young children ask about the Holy Spirit, with questions and "talk abouts" in the back of the book.

One of a series of Teddy Horsley books.

Pauline Latimer


"The Hard Sayings of Jesus" (June 1995 edition of magazine)

Author: FF Bruce, Hodder and Stoughton, £8.99

"Some of the sayings in the Gospels are difficult to understand and need explaining. Others are easy to understand, but hard to put into practice. In this unique book, F F Bruce looks at both kinds with honesty and insight." So states the paragraph on the back cover of this immensely useful and interesting book.

The sheer convenience of being able to turn straight to the appropriate page for a clear and easy to understand explanation of a "hard saying", saves so much time. I think most Christians would really appreciate this book and I highly recommend it.

Pauline Latimer


"Where does the Sea Go?" (August 1995 edition of magazine)

Author: Jan Godfrey, £2.99 (paperback) (A Tamarind Book, published in association with SU Publishing)

Billy Bear has gone to the seaside for the day with his family. Later, he is surprised to see that the sea is "running away". "Where does the sea go?" he asks his Mum, Dad and sister but they are too busy playing in the sea. Grandma has fallen asleep and even though a passing crab tell him it's "low tide" he still can't get a satisfactory answer to his question!

Finally, as his family all sit down together to eat their picnic, Grandma tells him about how God made the sea, explains about high and low tide, and more besides. A delightful book for 3/6 year olds and one to pack alongside the bucket and spade!! (One of a series of four Billy Bear books.)

Reviewed by Catherine Leteve (aged 9 years)


"After The Fire" (August 1995 edition of magazine)

Author: John Lockley £0.99 (paperback) (Published by Nelson Word)

Due to mankind's carelessness (as usual) and a mouse, a deadly epidemic wipes out the majority of the human race. A group of stunned survivors gather in a small English market town. They struggle to build a society better than the one that had collapsed around them, with the inevitable problems and differences that such a diverse group of people bring. I couldn't put this book down once I'd started it, very gripping reading! I hope there will be a sequel soon!

Reviewed by Catherine Leteve (aged 9 years)


"Telling the Sea" (August 1995 edition of magazine)

Author: Pauline Fisk

Telling the sea is a very good book about a girl named Nona who tells her feelings, secrets and happenings to the sea. Nona has many adventures by the sea including nearly drowning in its depths. It is quite sad but has a very nice ending. I enjoyed it a lot and I think other people will too.

Reviewed by Catherine Leteve (aged 9 years)


"Created for Love: understanding and building self-esteem" (October 1995 edition of magazine)

Authors: John and Agrees Stuart, £6.99

Many people today suffer the consequences of low self-esteem, yet to try to build up self-esteem can seem contrary to Christian teaching - putting self before others. However, this book, which has a sound scriptural base, looks at the issue carefully, dividing it into two parts. Part I explains how to understand self-esteem and recognise signs of good and poor self-esteem; and Part 2 concentrates on how to build up self-esteem.

At the end of each section there are reflections and exercises to be done individually or in a small group, but just to read the book quickly, concentrating on those areas that seem relevant, is very informative.

I found the book very interesting and I have learned a lot - time will tell! I particularly liked the creed of self-affirmation which states:
  • I believe that when God created me he did a good job. He looked at me and was very pleased.
  • I believe that I am made in the image of God. That image has been marred by sin, but there is a core of me which reflects God.
  • I believe that Christ died to release me to become the person he created me to be, and that he is at work in my life making this happen.
  • I believe that the things I see as blemishes, the things others may snigger at, God regards as part of my uniqueness.
  • I believe that. God loves me and that his love is unconditional, not depending on any virtue I may or may not possess, nor upon anything I have done or achieved.
The Bible calls this grace; I call it amazing!

Though I cannot grasp the full extent of God's love for me, I accept it as so, and I rejoice in it. I thank God for myself, for what I am and for what I am becoming. Through Jesus Christ, the Lord, Amen

Lindsay Leteve


"The Cat's Tail -Jesus at the Wedding" (October 1995 edition of magazine)

Collins Picture Lions by Nick Butterworth and Mick Inkpen £3.99

One of the most well known of Jesus' miracles is seen through the eyes of a local cat (who immediately notices something special about Jesus as soon as he spots him arriving in a crowd of wedding guests).

The party is quickly in full swing and everyone is having a great time them, panic stations!!! -the wine runs out!!

The cat is intrigued at Jesus instructions to the bemused servants who nevertheless fill 6 huge stone jars with water. ‘Water, what good is water at a wedding?’ Well, we all know what happens next! -and everyone parties on.

The cat goes off for his afternoon nap, waking up later when the celebrations are over and wonders if he dreamed it all. But then he sees the pink reflection of the moon shining on the remnants of wine in a stone jar and muses that "They haven't seen the last of Jesus, what an amazing man!"

This is one of our favourite books, the illustrations are terrific and the text could by read by a child aged 6+ but grown ups will enjoy reading it just as much!

There are 3 other books in the 'Tale" series, and will appeal to ages 3 upwards.

Pauline Latimer


"The Grumpy Shepherd" (December 1995 edition of magazine)

by Paddie Devon, Scripture Union Hard Back £5.99

Joram, the shepherd, is a seriously miserable man, a kind of biblical version of Victor Meldrew!!

This particular night, he is off to work as usual, up in the hills above Bethlehem, fed up with his job, sheep in general and can't be bothered to talk to his cheerful co-workers Josiah and Obed, preferring instead to go to sleep.

Although he is somewhat startled when Gabriel puts in an appearance, Joram is not too impressed with his message! Fortunately, his friends are and he is whisked off to see the new king (grumbling and complaining all the way of course!)

Upon arrival in Bethlehem, the three shepherds have no difficulty locating the stable, because the brightest star they have ever seen is lighting up the sky above it. As they cautiously push open the door, with even Joram now feeling slightly apprehensive, they are warmly welcomed by Mary and Joseph who lead them over to see the baby Jesus.

Joram's response to meeting Jesus is incredibly moving and changes his attitude and life forever, and we see him leaving the stable with his friends singing loudly and praising God!

If this book doesn't become Christmas classic for children, I shall eat my Christmas stocking! Beautifully written and illustrated, a book to treasure and will appeal to all ages.

Pauline Latimer


"How Do We Know The Bible Is True?" (Reasons a kid can believe it) by Lynn Waller (April 1996 edition of magazine)

Zondervan Publishing £4.50

Once you have picked up this book and started to read it, you'll probably have difficulty putting it down. Only after that will the children get a look in! Thus is an excellent book to have on hand when your children ask you questions about the Bible, especially if they have been teased by non-Christian friends who say the Bible isn't true, or out of date.

Our children do get some flack from time to time, about being Christians. The importance of being able to reassure them of Bible truths cannot be overstated. This book can't cover everything, but it makes a good job of what it does cover.

It's an easy, enjoyable and informative read, probably to suit age group 7 -12 and it has been written for children to read themselves. A Christian child would certainly be able to give a copy to a non believing friend to read.

I strongly recommend it.

Pauline Latimer


"Miracle in Mostar" by Gerard Kelly and Lowell Sheppard. (August 1996 edition of magazine)

"In 1993, 150,000 people were desperate to escape from the "hell" of the burning Bosnian city of Mostar" One young couple decided to buck the trend. Risking all, they moved to Mostar and started a revolution of love.

Buy the book (£4.99 through St Thomas' bookstall). Read the book, and be prepared to be challenged yourself!


Windows on the Cross by Tom Smail (December 1999 edition of magazine)

Society today shows signs of disintegration. Institutions such as the Monarchy, Parliament and the Church itself have come under intense scrutiny and deeply disturbing weaknesses have been exposed. We are bombarded with news of wars and injustice. The advance of science poses new moral dilemmas that leave us confused and looking for help.

In the midst of such perplexity Tom Smail invites us to "survey the wondrous cross", not he says to find instant answers to particular questions, but so that we can find our bearings and our confidence in the way God deals with the confusion and destructiveness in the world. We can also discover there clues about how we might respond to the difficult situations we have to face

The book examines many different perspectives of the cross: from the New Testament themes of reconciliation, sacrifice, justice and freedom to the more contemporary approaches of sharing of suffering and victory over sin. Throughout Tom Smail seeks to instruct and explain the biblical teaching, unlocking its meaning and motivating us to a fresh devotional and practical response to what God has done for us in the death of Jesus.

Publishers: Danton Longman & Todd


Cover to Cover Through the Bible As It Happened (June 2000 edition of magazine)

Are you like me and know that it's time to read the Bible from front to back again? But you find it hard going and you really have to gird your loins and grit your teeth and with grim determination press on: Genesis - wonderful reading, Exodus - fascinating, Numbers - monotonous, Leviticus - well? Deuteronomy - ditto ,1 and 2 Kings - ugh, Oh Father do you really want me to read Kings, again????

Well, thanks to Selwyn Hughes and Trevor J Partridge I am reading from Genesis to Revelation with eagerness and hunger. Why? Because this time I'm reading chronologically. As it happened. The fog is lifting, the fragmented jigsaw pieces are falling into place. I am experiencing a renewed awareness of the greatness of our God and am in awe (once again) of the depth of his love for his beloved children with whom I (we) number.

Each day there are a number of readings followed by a thought and a contemplation, and running along the bottom of each page is a date line (creation Noah flood Job etc)

I haven't reached Kings yet, but this time there is hope and expectancy in my heart instead of dread.

So I invite you to join me on the journey through the Bible with the aid of 'Cover to Cover Through the Bible As It Happened" by Selwyn Hughes and Trevor J Partridge. Each book of readings covers 60 days and a years supply costs £9.99 (I think) from: , CWR, PO Box 230, Farnham, Surrey, GU9 8XG, Tel: 01252 784710, www.cover2cover.org

Enid Sheldon


Harry Potter- Brilliant Idea or Bad Influence? (December 2000 edition of magazine)

In most children's diaries, and indeed those of many adults, a new occasion has been recorded; the annual publication of each new Harry Potter book. Why is it then that something which causes so much joy has been called unchristian and a dangerously bad influence?

Having read all the Harry Potter books, it is easy to see why some people have raised objections to them. The presence in the books of witches, ghosts and other unusual magical creatures has made a few people concerned- the children are being encouraged to take an interest in black arts and unchristian practices. The situation has got so bad that some schools have banned the books and an apparently Christian organisation in America has been sending death-threats to the author, J. K. Rowling. I fail to see how they are able to reconcile that with the Christian idea of the sanctity of life.

It is perfectly right to be concerned about the possible influence of these books. But the objectors are missing one major point: children are not letting themselves be adversely influenced by these books. Reading about someone being turned into a rat does not make them start trying to do the same to their friends; similarly they are not likely to go looking for unicorn blood to drink just because they read of it in Harry Potter. As the Bishop of Bolton, the Rt Revd David Gillett puts it, "Children know the difference between good and evil ... And they know they can't fly on broomsticks."

If we look more closely at the Harry Potter books we see that they are actually very easy to reconcile with the Christian message. Essentially they are about the struggle between good and evil, and if the early books are anything to go by, the good is almost certain to win! The combination of magic with the triumph of good over evil has led to many comparisons with the C. S. Lewis Narnia books, and no one denies the Christian message present in them. Another recurring theme is that of life after death. By this I don't mean the ghosts that float around the castle, but the relationship Harry has with his dead parents. I can put it no better than Dumbledore himself: "You think the dead we have loved ever truly leave us? You think that we don't recall them more clearly than ever in times of trouble? Your father is alive in you, Harry, and shows himself most plainly when you have need of him."

This brings us on to another very important message in the books: love. Harry owes his life to his mother's unconditional love for him, just as Lord Voldemort (Harry's enemy, the most evil wizard ever) owes his downfall to it. In a less dramatic, but equally important sense, the books show the development of Harry's relationships with his best friends Ron and Hermione. Loyalty and trust battle with jealously and many petty quarrels; but they come out best. In this way Harry is an ideal role model to all children.

Other examples of the good influence of these books are the celebration of Christmas, including the singing of Christmas carols; evidence of Christian influence even in today's secular society. Also the way the art of future gazing is clearly ridiculed and disapproved of even by the teachers, the emphasis being placed on non-magical values. Again it is Dumbledore who expresses this after the singing of the school song, "Music.. a magic beyond all we do here."

However there is a risk here of placing too much emphasis on the morality of the Harry Potter books. It must be remembered that they are really only amazingly good stories. They contain all the themes used in the best of children's books: the school story, the magical aspect, the presence of the evil aunt and uncle, and an incredible vocabulary of names and inventions such as Bertie Botts Every Flavour Beans (they really do come in every flavour, including baked beans, pepper, vomit and earwax)! Even if these books do contain a small amount of potentially harmful material, surely it is against the principles of our society to deny people the right to read them. Each individual, even a child, should have the right to choose what they read. Parents should be able to regulate this, but the Harry Potter books are not something that deserve censorship; they deserve merely to be enjoyed.

Rachel Perham

Rachel is a daughter of the Dean of Derby, the Very Revd Michael Perham.


Listen and Live" - Using the Bible in Prayer (June 2001 edition of magazine)

Author: Colin Urquhart Publisher: Hodder and Stoughton Price: £7.99

How can I pray more effectively?"
"How can I receive from God the blessings he promises?"

LISTEN AND LIVE is Colin Urquhart's response to these questions - based upon his own personal and pastoral experience, providing a way of praying nd reading the bible that is both powerful and effective.

Colin Urquhart has a gift of taking the most difficult of subjects and presenting them in a clear and simple way. It is written in language that is straightforward to follow, and yet the content is potentially very complex.

The author also writes in a very personal sense, as if you alone are the ntended recipient of his words. I am sure that most of us will have had this experience when reading the bible, and it can be extremely encouraging.

The book is divided into eight main sections, including themes such as 'fellowship with God', 'your life in Christ', and 'your life in holiness and glory'. The chapters are usually just two or three pages in length, and it is convenient (and advisable) to read this book little bits at a time.

I did find the introduction a little off-putting. It seemed to describe a "method" of praying which I feared might be rigid and legalistic. However I was soon reassured that the book is suitable for people who prefer a very structured approach, as well as for people who are perhaps less disciplined, and choose a more spontaneous way of worship and prayer. I have used this book personally as an alternativ has taken the best part of a year to read and certainly commend it to Christians, both new and more mature.

Mark Torkington


Two Children's Books Reviewed (June 2002 edition of magazine)

I have reviewed two books that I have shared and enjoyed with my own children. One is for the younger age group (perhaps 4-8 years) and the second is for slightly older children (perhaps 8 -12 years).

Many of the children's books are hard-back, and buying new books can prove relatively expensive, especially as children may grow out of them so quickly. I have chosen to review two simple books that are soft back, and each costs less than five pounds.

"Hello God It's Me" - This is a short collection of lively prayers published by Scripture Union, that is written by a Stephanie King (a teacher) and illustrated by Helen Mahood. It can be read with younger children to help them learn how to talk to God about everyday things such as learning, eating, wobbly teeth, playing and special times. It is a compact, bright book that it divided into several dozen short prayers, which should retain a small child's attention. Colourful pictures and suitable Bible verses complement the prayers. I would recommend this book to encourage parents to put aside a special prayer time each day to share with their children, and to help them to develop a loving relationship with God.

Stories of Jesus - This book was first written (by Tim Dudley-Smith) in 1971 and Lion Children's Books published this edition in 2000. It consists of 44 short episodes that are 2 or 3 pages in length. The episodes are linked together chronologically so that the ministry and life of Jesus unfolds in a natural, sequential and memorable manner. Many of the stories will be familiar and are soundly based on the Bible, with appropriate references pro-vided. The author has blended imaginative details with the gos-pel records to lend a colour and immediacy to the narration that makes for authentic and also compelling reading. It brings the times and characters, and the central figure of Jesus to life in a colourful and refreshing way.

Mark Torkington


A Perfect Gift for Christmas(October 2002 edition of magazine)

During the coronation, the new monarch is presented with the most precious gift known to man - it is a book, the bible - the word of God. At Christmas time, it can be difficult to find that perfect gift for friends and family. Have you considered a Christian book?

The bookstall presents many and varied books throughout the year. At present it is displaying two different children's publications. One is called "Hello God It's me" directed at younger children, and the second is titled "Stories of Jesus" which is more suitable for older children. Both books have recently been reviewed in Ploughshare and are now available to purchase from the bookstall.

What about a Christmas gift for loved ones who are perhaps a little older? Have you discovered the wonderful series of small books by Eddie Askew? Both he and his wife joined the Leprosy Mission in 1950, and worked for 15 years in India, before transferring to London, where Eddie became the International Director of the Mission in 1974 until his retirement in 1987. During this time Eddie produced a se-ries of meditations, which were published in a monthly newsletter for the Leprosy Mission's workers around the world.

These meditations have now been compiled into six books, each with approximately thirty chapters. The author has added a prayer and a drawing (or a painting in later publications) to compliment each medi-tation. Eddie Askew is certainly a gifted writer and artist, and these volumes are moving and thought provoking. Below is a small sample of part of one of his prayers.

Lord in the quietness
I feel your love
washing over me.
Lifting the dust, cleansing the dirt.
I feel your hands, firm,
gentle, with the towel.
I can take that.
What I find hard, too hard to take,
is seeing you kneeling
at my feet.

In the foreword to the sixth edition Wendy Craig puts it like this: "You have helped to open my eyes and my mind, and expanded and en-riched my whole experience of God's love".

Now what could be a more perfect Christmas gift.


A Life Worth Living – Exploring the Meaning of Life by Nicky Gumbel (December 2003 edition of magazine)

In future scientists will be able to prolong life for many people routinely to the age of 115 years. “But will it be worth living?” asks this book.

This book has been written by Nicky Gumbel whose previous book ‘Questions of Life” set out the material for the alpha course. It is an ideal book for those who have recently come to faith, and are beginning to study the bible. The book is written so well and so clearly, that I am sure it would serve very well to help renew and refresh fundamental Christian values for all readers.

Nicky Gumbel read law at Cambridge and theology at Oxford, and he practiced as a barrister, and is now ordained as a minister on the staff of Holy Trinity, Brompton. He has written many best-selling books about the Christian faith. He has an innate ability to present complex Christian theology in a light, often humorous and simple manner, which is easy to read and understand.

This book is based on Paul’s letter to the Philippians, and is a practical guide to help uncover a new heart, new purpose, new attitude and a new confidence in the way we live our lives. It is intended to be read in conjunction with bible passages (which are printed conveniently at the head of each chapter) and can be studied either by an individual or a group.

The apostle Paul found that Jesus Christ had made his life profoundly worth living and in his letter to the Philippians, Paul writes directly and indirectly about why this is the case, and how it can be for his readers as well.

This book is a positive guide to help readers achieve exactly what the title promises. It is available for a price of 5.99 through the bookstall, and comes strongly recommended.

Mark Torkington


Lift the Label -the hidden cost of our lifestyle by David Westlake and Esther Stansfield (August 2005 edition of the magazine)

Lift the Label is a practical book, calling us to connect our faith in God with our everyday lifestyle choices, linking how we spend our money to the millions working in poverty in order to feed and clothe us cheaply.

The book is in three sections.

The first introduces us to real people earning less than a living wage, working in appalling conditions, exploited and without rights.

The second outlines God’s heart for the poor and oppressed as revealed in the bible. It expresses our responsibilities as the people of God.

The third section guides you through ways you can shop ethically and campaign for changes to worker’s rights and international trade laws. The way we bank, buy, holiday and vote can change people’s lives.

The book contains a directory of organisations and ethically minded shops to help us to have a positive impact on our global neighbours when we hit the high street. This is a very worthwhile read.

Elaine Nudd


Fuelling the Fire – Fresh Thinking on Prayer - by Dennis Lennon (June 2006 edition of the magazine)

Publisher, Scripture Union – ISBN 1 84427 149 8

Here is a book on prayer that is both theological and practical, aiming to inspire readers about the value and privilege of prayer, with a wealth of fresh images and new light on biblical passages. The book deals in a robust and original way with the questions many Christians have about the prayer life. It is a great book that both challenged and encouraged me in my prayer life. I agree with one persons comment on the back cover, “Dennis Lennon should be locked in a room with a pen and paper and told to write until he could write no more ….”

David Mouncer


Builders and Fools: Leadership the Bible Way -Derek Tiball (June 2006 edition of the magazine)

Publisher IVP – ISBN – 0 85111 592 6

Builder, fool, ambassador, parent, pilot, scum, and shepherd: the apostle Paul used all these images when describing Christian leadership. Derek Tiball believes these images have important lessons and fresh insights for all who take leadership within a church. Do you lead a house group, do you serve on the PCC, a member of the M and M Leadership team, then this is the book for you.

David Mouncer


The Jesus I Never Knew -Philip Yancey (June 2006 edition of the magazine)

Publisher – Marshall Pickering – ISBN 0 00 710740 4

Philip Yancey writes, “Boring and predictable. No one could ever think of applying these words to the Jesus of the Gospels. How is it then, that the church has tamed such a character? The Jesus I got to know in writing this book is a very different from the Jesus I learned about as a child. In some ways he is more comforting: in some ways more terrifying.” In this book, Philip Yancey, strips away the stereotyped images to reveal the powerful and astonishing reality of Jesus. It’s easy to read and full of down to earth illustrations but also very powerful.

David Mouncer


The Herodian Stones -Gaynor Taylor (April 2008 edition of the magazine)

A review by Peter Cooney
Gaynor Taylor Novels set in the Holy Land during the time of Christ are nothing new: Ben Hur, Quo Vadis, The Robe – all were subsequently made into Hollywood blockbusters and still receiving regular airings on television.

What’s different about The Herodian Stones, the first novel by Gaynor Lynn Taylor (better known to us a Gaynor Roberts and member of St Thomas’ Church), is the idea of a detective story set against the New Testament backdrop of Christ’s death and resurrection.
The sleuth and hero of the tale is one Commander Marc Tiro, a high ranking Roman called in to investigate the disappearance of some priceless jewellery once owned by Cleopatra.

The unique stones should have been held alongside the Emperor Tiberius’s other treasures in the securely guarded vaults of Herodium, but much to the embarrassment of Pontius Pilate, when they are needed to fund some building works, the Herodian Stones have gone.

As Marc Tiro embarks upon his investigation we encounter brutal assassinations, decayed corpses, an ancient map with coded clues, dreadful family secrets and a strange religious sect. Interwoven into the tale are familiar names from the New Testament brought to life – Pilate, Mary Magdelene, Lydia, even a brief encounter with a pre-conversion Saul, the tentmaker.

It’s clear that the author has meticulously researched the culture, geography and history of the era, so as well as being educational, it all makes for a cracking good read. And who knows… is Russell Crowe available?

The Herodian Stones by Gaynor Lynn Taylor, £8.99, available from www.godsendbooks.com or from St Thomas’ Church.


The 'Good Stuff' Review: "The Straight Story" -Peter Cooney (June 2008 edition of the magazine)

Paul wrote to the Phillipians: “whatever is true, whatever is noble, whatever is pure, whatever is lovely, whatever is admirable – if anything is excellent or praiseworthy – think about such things”.

In our media saturated world this is not easy advice to follow (and perhaps was just as difficult for the Phillipians?). Every day we are bombarded with images, words and sounds that are just the opposite of the ideals set out by Paul. The media’s output can be explicit and in your face, or subtle and insinuating. We can knowingly seek it out, or it can catch us by surprise. However, it gets into our brains and it can do damage to our spiritual health.

That’s the bad news. The good news is – I believe there is a lot of good stuff out there that perhaps even an ex-Pharisee like Paul would enjoy.

So… I thought… why not draw attention to those things that I think are true, noble, pure, admirable, excellent etc. Books, films or any media that I have found that encourages my faith in the way Paul intended. The intention then is to do occasional reviews of films or books or anything else that builds us up, rather than drags us down. Hopefully, some of my choices will be surprising, even controversial. I intend to avoid the explicitly Christian since the intention is to share the good stuff out there that is less obvious. So let’s make a start with one of my favourite films:

The Straight Story
U certificate directed by David Lynch

The mention of David Lynch may raise a few eyebrows – the director of surreal and nightmarish movies such as Eraserhead, Blue Velvet and Mulholland Drive, as well as the controversial TV series Twin Peaks. Just the sort of output that Paul would probably say was best avoided. However, The Straight Story is not the usual David Lynch film.
Straight Story The story is based on real events: Alvin Straight is an ailing old man who has not spoken to his brother, Lyle, for many years. He receives news that Lyle has had a stroke and decides it is time he patched things up. Problem: brother lives 300 miles away, Alvin is not fit to drive a car and stubbornly refuses to use alternative transport. Solution: he decides to drive there on his motorised lawnmower! So the film becomes a very slow paced road movie as Alvin travels on the highways of the American Midwest encountering a host of great characters. I will say little more about the plot – get the DVD.

So, what is “noble, pure, admirable etc.” about The Straight Story? Well, apart from just being a moving and entertaining film, I believe it communicates in a beautiful way some great truths:
1. Saying sorry, patching things up with those family or friends we have fallen out with isn’t easy. It takes effort, imagination and perseverance, but it is a good thing to do. As well as Alvin’s quest, there is a touching scene when Alvin meets a pregnant teenager, homeless and estranged from her family.

2. There are a lot of good people in the world who will offer help to the vulnerable given the opportunity. This is a message that has become quite alien to our culture. So many modern films (David Lynch’s included) portray a world dominated by characters who seem irredeemably evil, violent, and ruthless. But is that a balanced view of reality? There is evil in the world, yes, but there is also a lot of good and it is nice to see it getting some serious attention for a change.

3. Old age, disease and infirmity are no fun, but they don’t mean we should wallow in self pity. In researching this piece I discovered that Richard Farnsworth, the actor who played Alvin Straight, was actually suffering from terminal bone cancer during filming (and sadly died of a self inflicted gun shot wound a year later). The physical pain you see as Alvin struggles with the demands of the journey and everyday life is real and his reaction to his failing health is brutally honest. He tells a fit young football player who asks about old age: “The worst part of being old? It’s remembering when you were young”. But Alvins’s disabilities don’t detract from his humanity, they enhance it. He isn’t less of a man just because there are things he can no longer do. When the time has come to do the right thing, he gets on and does it.

4. It is good to slow down! Alvin has no real choice in the matter, the lawnmower plods along at walking pace and his journey takes weeks. Our culture says if we slow down the pace of our life we are going to miss out on something – we have got to pack in as much as we can and be constantly rushing on to the next event. Alvin’s shows us slowing down can actually enrich our lives and create space and opportunity for relationships to develop.

It’s a great film, catch it on Video or DVD it if you can.

Peter Cooney


Two Books for Advent ‘The Meaning is in the Waiting: The Spirit of Advent’ and ‘The Shack’ (December 2008 edition of the magazine)
More information, price and an order form see the leaflet here
Meaning of waiting cover Advent is traditionally a season of spiritual preparation for the coming of Jesus. I would like to invite you to consider two books to read together during this time to help us be ready in a new way for an old truth. -Matt Barnes

Paula Gooder’s book ‘The Meaning is in the Waiting: The Spirit of Advent’ is a traditional Advent volume helping us to see ‘waiting’ as not ‘wasting’ time. Paula is a very deep theologian but her learning is not overbearing in this very accessible devotional read, divided into 24 short meditations. Helpful, insightful and well written, you can’t go wrong! (See review below.)
Go for this if:
-You’re too busy to read an Advent book;
-You like more traditional Christian literature; You’re looking for biblical insights.

As my ‘left-field’ choice I offer you ‘The Shack’ by William P. Young. It’s a novel; it will not be what you expect.
The Shack cover It may be uncomfortable and it is certainly not conventional as it’s not theology as we probably think of it. It should be said that it’s loved and loathed in equal measure, but for my money its attempt to communicate something about God in such a fresh and unusual way is worth a read. Watch out for the interesting insights into the incarnation and the nature of the relationship between the Trinity.

Go for this if:
-You like novels;
-You’re struggling with pain in your life;
-You enjoy being challenged to think ‘outside the box’.
For those who are interested, I’d be pleased to invite anyone who would like to come and discuss these books together to do so at the Rectory on Monday, 22 December at 8pm. Sherry and mince pies will be available!

Visit 'The Shack' website here

Rev Matt Barnes


A review of 'The Meaning is in the Waiting' -written by Paula Gooder (December 2008 edition of the magazine)
Meaning of waiting cover Paula Gooder’s premise that Advent is a time to anticipate the coming of Christ prayerfully and celebratory is a timely reminder to Christians that we are in the world, but not of it and that deferring gratification may be a key to spiritual growth.

The preface, written by Dr John Sentamu the Archbishop of York, calls the book ‘a masterly bulwark’ and encourages us to ‘make it last through Advent’. However, on your behalf, I read it in one week.

It is a traditional potted history of major and some minor players in the Advent narrative using the Advent wreath as a devise to illuminate (pardon the pun) the journey to Bethlehem.

The text begins with some musings on the purpose of ‘waiting’, suggesting that ‘the meaning is in the waiting’ and can be an activity filled with possibility rather than passively hanging around, longing for the main event. An accessible meditation both for the uninitiated and readers familiar with the intricacies of the House of David’s line: we start with Abraham and Sarah and meander to Mary. Pausing to ponder the Prophets and contemplate that most patient of men: John the Baptist, along the way.
Gooder encourages us to look at Advent as a time of ‘nurture’ and ‘valuable in its own right’ and considers that to be unable to wait might preclude us from being fully present in the now. The further reading suggestions are useful and increase the opportunities for reflection, meditation and contemplation. The text is an ideal companion for active waiting.

Each one of us has a way of engaging with Advent; mine is finding a Messiah from scratch to attend during December. In addition, I play my recording of Handel’s divine oratorio sung by the Huddersfield choir, until my husband begs for mercy. As the tenor voice opens with ‘Comfort thee…’ the hairs on the back of my neck stand up and my eyes fill with tears.

So, this Advent don’t just ignore the biscuits shaped like snowmen and the gaudy tinsel strands coming soon to a supermarket near you. Refuse to enter into those brain numbing ‘ready for Christmas yet?’ conversations and become an active ‘waiter’ for Christ and a prayerful reader of the Advent story. Gooder’s text may supply a new way of looking at this important time in the Christian calendar.

Reviewed by Millie Guthrie

Published by Canterbury Press £8.99, ISBN No: 9781853119088


A review of 'The Shack' -written by William P Young (February 2009 edition of the magazine)

In Advent 2008 Matt, our Rector, suggested we read two books: ‘The Meaning is in the Waiting: The Spirit of Advent’ and ‘The Shack’. Millie Guthrie reviewed the former in the last edition of Ploughshare. Now Millie reviews ‘The Shack’.
The Shack cover The much discussed novel ‘The Shack’ is my text for dissection this month. Apparently the author William P Young tried many publishing houses and no one was willing to print it -so he did it himself!

Whilst struggling through the first chapter I could see why. Until I become immersed in the message of the text the overtly simplistic, sentimental American style made my teeth ache and I did wonder if I could bear to read on. The text is a work of fiction and some considerable suspension of belief is called for. Without revealing too much, the main protagonist is Mack and it is his encounter with the living, breathing God taking human form that drives the text.
On a family camping trip in Oregon Mack and his relationship with God are changed by the abduction and tragic murder of his youngest daughter. He enters a period he calls ‘The Great Sadness’. God cannot reach him. He blames himself and God for the death of his daughter; he becomes isolated from God’s love and can find no peace.

He wallows in despair and guilt for four years until salvation arrives in the very place where his daughter was murdered: The Shack. He is invited back by ‘Papa’ AKA God.

This is where the text moves from a memoir into magical realism with the Trinity appearing in an interesting way. Large theological debates develop with God attempting to answer Mack’s questions and show him that love and forgiveness still exist for him.

I won’t reveal the end as it does become an interesting, challenging read. Just be prepared to read it as an extended metaphor and you will not be disappointed.

Reviewed by Millie Guthrie

I have read ‘The Shack’ and found it challenging with some thought provoking concepts about God. If anyone else who has read it would like to express their opinion or thoughts in print please send them to me. –Editor.


The 'Good Stuff' Review: "Sophie Scholl – The Last Days " -Peter Cooney (February 2009 edition of the magazine)
(2005 PG certificate)
Directed by Marc Rothemund. German with English subtitles

Let’s be honest – the Nazis and the Holocaust are awkward subjects for Christians. The greatest crime against humanity in recent history, arguably, in all of history, was perpetrated by a nation that nominally called itself Christian. In the decades immediately after the Second World War it was commonly thought that the crimes were committed by a minority of Nazi fanatics and conscripted soldiers “reluctantly following orders”. However, research published in recent years has suggested most ordinary Germans were well aware of the barbarity of the Nazi regime. To quote the historian Daniel Goldhagen, many thousands became Hitler’s ‘willing executioners’.
Sophie Scholl poster The story is based on real events: Alvin Straight is an ailing old man who has not spoken to his brother, Lyle, for many years. He receives news that Lyle has had a stroke and decides it is time he patched things up. Problem: brother lives 300 miles away, Alvin is not fit to drive a car and stubbornly refuses to use alternative transport. Solution: he decides to drive there on his motorised lawnmower! So the film becomes a very slow paced road movie as Alvin travels on the highways of the American Midwest encountering a host of great characters. I will say little more about the plot – get the DVD.

So, what is “noble, pure, admirable etc.” about The Straight Story? Well, apart from just being a moving and entertaining film, I believe it communicates in a beautiful way some great truths:
It is against the background of this violent, racist and evil society that the story of Sophie Scholl and the White Rose Movement of Munich University is so remarkable. The chilling truth is that examples of resistance by German Christians to the Nazi regime are not easy to find in the history of the period – but one shining example is Sophie Scholl and her brother Hans. The film is based on the last days of Sophie’s life and the script draws upon the records kept by the German authorities only made available in 1990 with the collapse of the East German regime.

The plot is simple. Sophie (Julia Jentsch) and her brother are caught red-handed distributing anti-Nazi leaflets at Munich University in February 1943. It is a bad time to be critical of the regime – news of large-scale atrocities committed on the eastern front and the catastrophic defeat of the German army at Stalingrad are filtering back to the general population. After Sophie’s arrest, a senior Gestapo officer, Robert Mohr (Alexander Held), interrogates her over a period of three days.

It is these series of interrogations, based on actual Gestapo records, which make up the heart of the film. Mohr is clearly an intelligent and astute policeman, and his forensic questioning of Sophie soon breaks down her initial claims of innocence. As Sophie comes to terms with the fact that the evidence gathered against her means she is doomed, she engages Mohr in a debate on the whole basis of Hitler’s National Socialism. It is intelligent, moving, and inspirational as this young defenceless girl fearlessly exposes the lies and inhumanity that sustain the regime. It is great cinema as the committed Gestapo officer vents his anger and frustration at what he sees as Sophie’s misguided opposition to the regime, whilst Sophie’s replies slowly, but surely, begin to undermine his whole belief in the National Socialist system.

The film moves on to a show trial presided over by the Nazi regime’s most senior judge, the notorious Roland Friesler. The public gallery is packed out with senior military officers and party officials murmuring approval as Friesler bullies and rants against Sophie and her co-defendants (again based on actual court records). However, the onlookers grow more and more uncomfortable as Sophie and Hans defend themselves with dignity and courage, and defend truth itself, against Friesler’s hate filled onslaughts. You can feel the chill spread through the courtroom as Sophie turns to them and says: “You will soon be standing where we stand now”.

The sentence passed by the court is no surprise and the final section of the film is the short time Sophie spends in custody awaiting execution. Have a box of tissues ready.

In light of the tragic ending you might wonder why I find this film uplifting and encouraging to my faith? Well, I suppose like all stories of martyrdom it inspires courage and perseverance. I won’t spoil the plot, but Sophie has a chance to save herself from the death penalty by betraying other members of the Movement – Mohr is desperate that she does so, but Sophie remains steadfast to her beliefs. In the midst of the darkness and evil of the regime, Sophie is a shining light of truth and goodness that even the most hardened Nazis are impotent to contradict – their only answer is violence.

I felt the real tragedy of the film is the question: why weren’t there more Sophie Scholl’s in Germany in the 1930s and 40s? And the hard question for us in 21st Century is: can we have the same insight and courage as Sophie to recognise and oppose our own culture and society when it perpetrates brutality and evil in our name?

Peter Cooney


A review of 'Suprised by Hope' -written by Tom Wright (June 2010 edition of the magazine)

Carolyn Baker reviews Tom Wright’s book ‘Surprised by Hope’ which we studied during Lent this year.
Suprised by Hope book cover ‘Jesus’ resurrection is the beginning of God’s new project, not to snatch people away from earth to heaven but to colonize the earth with the life of heaven. That after all is what the Lord’s prayer is about’. Tom Wright - Surprised by Hope

In his book Tom Wright sets about the task of getting to the heart of the biblical truths about the resurrection of Jesus and what this means for Christians today. This is done against a backdrop of the wide variety of beliefs and sentiments that are held today and which are attributed to Christianity by Non-Christians, Christians and the Church.
Wright begins by demonstrating the muddle and confusion about death and life after death that exists in the twenty first century using snapshots of events that will be familiar to most readers of the book. Using these modern day examples he demonstrates his premise that ‘most people simply don’t know what orthodox Christian belief might be’ about life after death and resurrection. He doesn’t baulk at suggesting that this extends into churches and illustrates how this confusion has arisen historically through well known literature, poetry, scientific advances and philosophies such as Platonism. This is demonstrated by the Church today in its use of some familiar hymns and liturgy which continue to exacerbate this confusion.

Having examined our current predicament, Wright takes us back to the world of the early Christians, examining their beliefs against the backdrop of both Pagan and Jewish views on the resurrection and life after death. This culminates in the final chapter of this first section entitled The Strange Story of Easter. This is a detailed examination of the gospel accounts of the first Easter day, placing them in the context of the Jewish beliefs at that time and explaining how the early followers of Jesus were not expecting or looking for the events that actually happened.

By the end of this first section of the book Wright has built up his case for the view that the resurrection of Jesus is not an odd event, not a take it or leave it event within the present world, but the defining event of God’s new creation. The resurrection was the death of death.

On first reading, part two, God’s Future Plan left me gasping for breath as I was simultaneously excited by the content whilst being intellectually and theologically stretched. Wright challenges us to ask new questions and adopt new perspectives as he develops his argument that the early Christians believed that God was going to do for the whole cosmos what he had done for Jesus at that first Easter. Wright reasons that the hope that lies in the veryreal resurrection of Jesus is the future that God has already begun to bring forward to meet us in the present. This applies not just to us as individual human beings but to the whole cosmos.

This is exciting stuff when you then project this idea onto what this means for Christians and the Church today. Wright explores this in part three, Hope In Practice. His challenge is that our life now is not about ‘making the present life a little less beastly, a little more bearable while we are here’, not about making ‘the best of a bad job’ whilst waiting to leave our bodies behind and for our souls to go to a better place. No, our life is about what we do here that will last into God's future -which is the final coming together of heaven and earth. The strength through which we do this is not our own strength but the power of the Holy Spirit. ‘The Holy Spirit is given so we can be in a measure what Jesus himself was, part of God’s future arriving in the present. The Holy Spirit comes from the world that is waiting to be born.’

There has been some criticism that Wright avoids the issue of judgement. However he argues that the point is ‘not to focus on the question of which human beings God is going to take to heaven, and how he is going to do it, but on the question of how God is going to redeem and renew his creation through human beings’. Our life as Christians, through the transforming power of the Holy Spirit, is to live as intersecting points between heaven and earth, living a life that celebrates and embodies new creation.

The role of the Church in building for the kingdom in terms of bringing justice, beauty and evangelism to the communities it serves is eloquently described by Wright: ‘people worship the God in whose image they are made, as they follow the Lord who bore their sins and rose from the dead, as they are indwelt by the spirit and thereby given new life, a new way of life, a new zest for life’.

The mission of the church to be outward looking, working within the world as a vehicle of redemption and healing and looking forward to the time when heaven and earth become one.

As someone new to bible study and theology I found this book both challenging and stimulating. If you want a shortcut then read the two Easter sermons in the tailpiece. They will give you a flavour of what the book is about. However by doing this you will deprive yourself of the journey that is this book.

There is much, much more in this book than I have been able to do justice to in this article, but if you are open to being challenged in your understanding of the Hope that that first Easter brought to this world then read this book.

Carolyn Baker

You can listen to the Lent Course here


A commentry on 'The Divine Image' -written by William Blake (October 2010 edition of the magazine)

‘The Divine Image’
by William Blake

To Mercy, Pity, Peace and Love
All pray in their distress;
And to these virtues of delight
Return their thankfulness.

For Mercy, Pity, Peace and Love
Is God, our father dear,
And Mercy, Pity, Peace and Love
Is Man, His child and care.

For Mercy has a human heart,
Pity a human face,
And love, the human form divine,
And Peace, the human dress.

Then every man, of every clime,
That prays in his distress,
Prays to the human form divine,
Love, Mercy, Pity, Peace.

And all must love the human form,
In heathen, Turk or Jew;
Where Mercy, Love and Pity dwell
There God is dwelling too.

The poem has the repeating line; ‘Mercy, Pity, Peace and Love’, referring to qualities of superior virtue. The poem suggests that if these are attributes of God, and man being made in God’s image is where these qualities can be found.

To me this reminds me that it is not enough to pray “God solve that problem over there”, but to be prepared to act out the solution, because God’s answer to prayer comes through people, me included. It is poignant to consider that God made us all different, hence the reference to ‘In heathen, Turk or Jew’.

The 18th century common Englishman might have had even less opportunity to exercise tolerance and racial equality than our 21st century multi-cultural society allows. ‘Where Mercy, Love and Pity dwell, there God is dwelling too’. We are all made in God’s image no matter who or where.

Paula Simons


A review of 'The Radical Disciple' -written by John Stott (February 2011 edition of the magazine)

Sue Wheeler reviews John Stott's book ‘The Radical Disciple’ which we read during Advent last year.
Radical Disciple cover The media these days are always looking for the ‘sound bite’, the short sentence that summarises an interview or a comment to grab people’s attention. Well I’m going to struggle to select any ‘sound bites’ from this book as it has several gems on every page!

This is hardly surprising as the author, John Stott, is a very well respected writer and theologian who has been inspiring Christians for over sixty years.

Perhaps this, his final book, is the sound bite of all he has written, a distilling of his life’s works and personal journey. Indeed I felt, as I read it, as if every paragraph was heavy with significance.
must admit I was a little apprehensive when I started the book as I understood Stott to be quite an academic writer. However I needn’t have worried.

The book explores eight characteristics of Christian Discipleship which, Stott suggests, are very important but often neglected. These are: Non-conformity, Christ-likeness, Maturity, Creation-care, Simplicity, Balance, Dependence and Death.

These themes are unpacked very clearly and succinctly with a sense of authority which often felt quite uncompromising and uncomfortable in their challenge. Indeed, one commentator on the book referred to it as a clarion call to Christians and I did feel I was being shaken and told “wake up, it’s obvious, this is how you should be living”. I have been led to ponder how much my life style actually reflects my faith but interestingly, unlike other books I have read, I was not left feeing condemned but rather challenged and encouraged to change.

The chapter on Dependence took on a huge significance for me as I am currently off work and, temporarily, quite immobile after I broke my ankle recently, slipping on the ice. As a formerly fiercely independent and busy person I now find my self helpless and vulnerable. It has been a challenge but this chapter helped me to find comfort in this uncomfortable state.

The book concludes very movingly with the author’s post script entitled ‘Farewell!’ I felt I had shared an intimate moment with this man as he ties up his affairs and prepares, with confidence, to meet his maker. I am sure this is all the more poignant for those readers who are more familiar with Stott’s works and who have been encouraged on their own journeys by him.

I would strongly commend this book to any Christian, wherever they are on their journey with Christ. I suspect that if we allow this book to change us into radial disciples, living authentic Christ-like lives, God’s love and hope will become abundantly visible in our community.

Sue Wheeler


A review of 'Chariots of Fire' -30 years on (June 2011 edition of the magazine)

Chariots of Fire It was thirty years ago that the Oscar winning film Chariots of Fire had its premier. Many of us remember it for its wonderful theme music and those poinient scenes of the Olympic runners training as they ran along a beautiful white beach and through the surf. The film was the inspired work of the writer Colin Welland and was directed by Hugh Hudson and produced by David Putnam. It focuses on two British track runners, one a devout Christian, Eric Liddell (Ian Charleson) and the other, an ambitious Jewish man, Harold Abrahams (Ben Cross) during the build up to the 1924 Olympic Games in Paris.
You may also remember the several profound religious and ethical themes running through the film and how the runners stood up to and faced these issues. These included Liddell refusing to run on a Sunday and anti Semitism and class distinction that was faced by Abrahams.

The film is considered a classic and is still being shown.

A few memorable quotes by Eric Liddell:

“I believe God made me for a purpose, for China [where Liddell later went as a missionary]. He also made me fast and when I run I feel His pleasure.”

“God made countries, God makes kings, and the rules by which they govern. And those rules say that the Sabbath is His. And I for one intend to keep it that way.”

“You can praise God by peeling a spud if you peel it to perfection. Don't compromise. Compromise is a language of the devil. Run in God's name and let the world stand back and in wonder.”

“I want you to do more than just watch a race. I want you to take part in it. I want to compare faith to running in a race. It's hard. It requires concentration of will, energy of soul…….. Everyone runs in their own way. And where does the power come from, to see the race to its end? From within. Jesus said, "Behold, the Kingdom of God is within you. If with all your hearts, you truly seek me, you shall ever surely find me." Commit yourself to the love of Christ. That is how you run a straight race.”


'Son of Man' -film review (June 2011 edition of the magazine)
Son of Man This is the film we watched during Holy Week 2011 at St Thomas’

The film sets the Jesus story in the context of a modern, African township. Were Jesus to come to earth today it's not hard to imagine that this is the kind of place we would find him, criticising the politics and corruption that leaves millions living in shacks. Pilate's troops pose as agents of peace from a neighbouring country. He maintains his power by using local gangland leaders Caiaphas and Annas to keep control of their people. The Jesus in the film is almost the polar opposite of the image of Jesus most of us grew up with. Rather than blond hair and a white bathrobe he is a shaven headed black-African dressed in jeans and a checked shirt. Yet it is easy to relate to him in the role because Andile Kosi, who plays Jesus, effortlessly blends strength, compassion, and an easy going nature, with a compelling and passionate personality.
Telling the story in such a modern setting also makes it a lot more real. Herod’s slaughter of the infants is brought uncomfortably close to home, creating fear and tension even though we know Jesus’ survival is assured. The disciples are drawn from both peaceful men (and women) and from freedom fighters who are challenged to lay down the weapons as well as their lives.

The director also uses various other touches to reinvigorate the story, including shooting some of the film’s narration in the style of news footage, and showing the miracles filmed with a camcorder. These are nicely blended with more naturalistic, and intimate footage to prevent them becoming gimmicky, or the film becoming too much of a documentary.

The film also comments on the way Jesus’ activity was recorded and preserved for a wider audience. As well as the filming of Jesus’ miracles his other actions start to be recorded and celebrated. These include murals on the walls of the township, re-telling the stories about him to a wider audience in language the local people can understand. Jesus’ popularity grows, and he begins to pose more of a threat to those in power.

The film’s handling of the first Easter has upset some. It would spoil the ending to say more, but essentially it tries to tell the story in a way that would be realistic to the films modern context. Suffice to say that it’s a political end to a very politically charged version of the Christ story.

Whilst the film has little doubt about Jesus’ divinity - showing a number of his miracles and prayers, it’s the political aspect of Jesus’ brief time on earth that is the film’s biggest concern. Many European and American Christians, living in a culture where religion and theology have been almost totally separated, will not be entirely comfortable with this. Yet Jesus’ core message in this film is This is my world - a statement that is both political and theological. When the early Christians claimed Jesus was King and Lord of all the world, they were also implying that Caesar wasn’t. Such radical, political statements lie at the heart of Son of Man, and setting the story in a more politically charged context gives us a much needed reminder.